Differences between sumi-e, suibokuga and shodō

flores kaoru

Sumi-e (墨絵), also known as suibokuga, is a monochromatic painting technique that originated in China and reached its peak in Japan during the Muromachi period (14th–16th centuries). Inspired by Zen Buddhism, sumi-e pursues simplicity, spiritual clarity and the ability to express the essence of a landscape, a flower or an animal with just a few strokes.

In Japan, this discipline was cultivated in temples and monasteries as part of meditative practice. The act of loading the brush with ink and placing it on rice paper was in itself an exercise in mindfulness. Over the centuries, sumi-e ceased to be an exclusively monastic activity and became an art form practised by court painters, samurai and later by contemporary artists.

If you would like to know more about how it differs from shodō (Japanese calligraphy), you can read the article Differences between sumi-e, suibokuga and shodō.

First contacts with the West: the 16th century

The first Japanese objects to arrive in Europe, via Jesuit missionaries and Portuguese and Spanish traders, included fans, screens and works with a sumi-e aesthetic. Although ink art was not the highlight of these early exports, it did spark an initial fascination with Japanese exoticism.

However, this influence was limited until the country opened up in the 19th century. For more than two centuries, Tokugawa shogunate Japan remained closed to much of the world, and it was only with the Meiji Restoration (1868) that true cultural interaction took place.

Japonism and 19th-century European fascination

With the opening of Japan to international trade, thousands of artistic objects flooded into Europe. Japonism became a fashionable trend and a source of artistic inspiration. Painters such as Claude Monet, Vincent van Gogh and James Whistler were attracted to Japanese aesthetics. Although they did not practise sumi-e directly, they were inspired by its principles: asymmetrical compositions, use of empty space and a poetic view of nature.

In Paris, the Universal Expositions presented Japanese ink scrolls that aroused the curiosity of Western artists. In this context, some art workshops began to offer basic sumi-e lessons to an audience eager to experiment with “the Japanese stroke”.

Expansion in the 20th century: America and Europe

In the 20th century, sumi-e came to be practised beyond Japan by artists residing in the West.

United States

During the post-war period, many Japanese teachers emigrated to the United States and began teaching sumi-e at universities and cultural centres. In California, sumi-e blended with Zen culture, already popularised by figures such as D. T. Suzuki. Japanese painters and calligraphers found a place in the United States to spread their techniques, and sumi-e began to be practised both as an art form and as therapy.

Europe

In Europe, especially in France, Germany and the United Kingdom, sumi-e became integrated into art academies. Its relationship with abstract expressionism and minimalism was evident: artists such as Franz Kline and Mark Tobey displayed a style reminiscent of the expressive power of Japanese ink.

If you want to read about how sumi-e adapts to the present, don’t miss The Reinterpretation of Japanese Painting in Contemporary Art.

Adaptations and differences in the West

Although the core of sumi-e remains intact, there are notable changes in its adaptation to the West:

  • Colour: instead of being limited to black, many artists use coloured inks.

  • Media: in addition to rice paper, it is painted on canvas, ceramics and even textiles.

  • Themes: while bamboo, plum trees and mountains predominate in Japan, in the West urban landscapes, portraits and modern scenes are also included.

These adaptations do not detract from the value of sumi-e, but rather demonstrate how it is capable of engaging with different cultural contexts.

For those who want to try it from scratch, I recommend checking out The Use of Ink and Brush in Japanese Painting.

Sumi-e in Latin America

In Latin American countries with a strong Japanese immigrant presence, such as Brazil, Peru, and Mexico, sumi-e also found fertile ground. In São Paulo, for example, Nikkei communities keep the tradition of calligraphy and ink painting alive, passing on this art in intergenerational workshops.

In Mexico, some universities have incorporated sumi-e workshops as part of their Eastern art and culture programmes, building a bridge between ancient Japanese traditions and Latin American sensibilities.

Sumi-e as mindfulness in the West

One of the most notable adaptations of sumi-e in the West has been its relationship with mindfulness and well-being. The act of slowly drawing a line or painting a bamboo leaf with conscious breathing became a therapeutic method for reducing stress and promoting mindfulness.

This approach has led many schools to offer sumi-e not only as an artistic technique, but also as a tool for active meditation.

To learn more about the benefits of this practice, visit the sumi-e benefits category.

Sumi-e in the digital age

Today, with graphics tablets and illustration software, Western artists have recreated the aesthetics of sumi-e in digital format. Although the unique texture of rice paper and natural ink is lost, the philosophy of minimalist strokes and the expressiveness of emptiness remain.

There are even digital exhibitions that combine sumi-e with animation, projecting immersive spaces in galleries where mountains, bamboo, and koi fish seem to come to life.

International reference: the MET

The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York houses one of the most comprehensive collections of Oriental art outside Japan. Its Ink Paintings section includes sumi-e masterpieces that illustrate the connection between tradition and modernity, as well as its influence on Western artists.

Frequently asked questions

When did sumi-e become popular in Europe?
At the end of the 19th century, thanks to Japonism and the opening up of Japan.

What is the difference between Japanese and Western sumi-e?
Japanese sumi-e is more faithful to monochrome and the Zen tradition, while Western sumi-e incorporates colour, new media and modern motifs.

Where can I learn sumi-e outside Japan?
Currently, you can do so at schools and also online. Explore the in-person courses and online classes you will find on this site.

Invitation

Sumi-e is not just a technique, but a way of looking at the world. Its journey from Japan to the West reflects art’s ability to cross borders and unite cultures.

If you want to start practising and discover the beauty of this ancient art in your daily life, I invite you to learn about our sumi-e courses.

Artículo escrito por Kaoru Hirose, artista y profesora de Sumi-e con más de 10 años de experiencia enseñando en Europa y Japón.

Kaoru Hirose

Kaoru Hirose

Artista y profesora de Sumi‑e certificada por la International Sumi‑e Association de Tokio. Ha impartido cursos y exposiciones en Barcelona, Sitges, Berlín y otras ciudades europeas desde 2013.
Puedes seguir su trabajo en Instagram, conectarte con ella en LinkedIn o descubrir más en su perfil de Facebook.

Leer biografía completa
Newsletter
Recibe noticias sobre sumi-e
No, gracias
close-link
Scroll to Top